Patent Filings Roundup: Latest Mohan Rao Vehicle Semiconductor Patents Challenged; Competitor Suits Dominate

https://depositphotos.com/40634949/stock-photo-golden-light-bulb-fighting-duel.htmlIt was a relatively average week for patent filings, with 58 district court complaints and 19 new Patent Trial and Appeal Board petitions filed—that’s a tad low—all inter partes reviews (IPRs). There were more fake meat IPRs filed against Impossible Foods by Motif Foodworks; no discretionary denials last week; lots of frequent litigants saw IPRs instituted against asserted patents this week; unknown Qualserve Solutions LLC sued Samsung on what appears to be standard-essential LTE networking functions, though it’s unclear how handsets would exactly infringe; AGIS and Verizon appear to have settled; Speir Technologies [Magentar Capital] went down the line and hit TCL (after reportedly offering a five-year RPX license to settle all Magnetar suits with their members).

Latest Asserted Mohan Rao Patents Challenged

Dell filed petitions against Greenthread LLC, an LLC part-owned by frequent litigant-inventor G.R. Mohan Rao and funded by a relatively new litigation funder; the original assignment turned over 14 semiconductor patents to Greenthread, at least some of which have been asserted, some early against Samsung, Sony, and now five against Dell and Intel in Texas; the portfolio has been split and patents have been put in to at least two other litigation vehicles, Vervain, LLC and Flash-Control, LLC; Vervain sued Micron and Western Digital on memory on four patents, all of which have pending IPR challenges from Micron at the Board; Flash-Control, which was associated with Brian Yates, had sued Micron, Kingston, Intel, and ADATA Technology as far back as 2016, with cases (and IPRs) there continuing on.

                                  PTAB (19)

Case Number Action Owner Petitioner Patent
IPR2023-00485 Filed K-Fee System Gmbh Nespresso USA, Inc. 11230430
IPR2023-00480 Filed Merck Serono S.A. [Merck & Co., Inc.] Hopewell Pharma Ventures, Inc. 7713947
IPR2023-00506 Filed Greenthread LLC [G.R. Mohan Rao, funded] Dell Technologies Inc.
Dell Inc.
10510842
IPR2023-00510 Filed Greenthread LLC [G.R. Mohan Rao, funded] Dell Technologies Inc.
Dell Inc.
11316014
IPR2023-00508 Filed Emkinetics Inc. Cala Health, Inc. 9757584
IPR2023-00503 Filed Zanoprima Lifesciences, Ltd. Hangsen International Group Ltd. 10913962
IPR2023-00515 Filed Corrigent Corporation Arista Networks, Inc. 7330431
IPR2023-00154 Filed Plotagraph, Inc.
Sascha Connelly
Lightricks Ltd. 10621469
IPR2023-00504 Filed Omega Patents, LLC Geotab USA, Inc.
Geotab, Inc.
8032278
IPR2023-00521 Filed Terves, LLC [Powdermet, Inc] Chongqing Yanmei Technology Co., LTD 10689740
IPR2023-00321 Filed Impossible Foods Inc. Motif Foodworks, Inc. 10689656
IPR2023-00502 Filed K-Fee System Gmbh Nespresso USA, Inc. 10994923
IPR2023-00479 Filed Polaris PowerLED Technologies, LLC [Microchip Technology Incorporated] Samsung Electronics Co., LTD
Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
8740456
IPR2023-00507 Filed Greenthread LLC [G.R. Mohan Rao, funded] Dell Technologies Inc.
Dell Inc.
10734481
IPR2023-00511 Filed Emkinetics Inc. Cala Health, Inc. 9387338
IPR2023-00312 Filed Slingshot Printing LLC Canon USA, Inc 7484823
IPR2023-00322 Filed Impossible Foods Inc. Motif Foodworks, Inc. 10273492
IPR2023-00481 Filed Merck Serono S.A. [Merck & Co., Inc.] Hopewell Pharma Ventures, Inc. 8377903
IPR2023-00509 Filed Greenthread, LLC Dell Technologies Inc.
Dell Inc.
11121222
IPR2022-01326 Not Instituted – Merits Mayborn UK Limited [Ping An Insurance (Group) Company of China, Ltd.] Comotomo Corporation
Comotomo Inc.
11207244
IPR2022-01274 Not Instituted – Merits Masimo Corporation
Cercacor Laboratories Inc
Apple Inc 10912502
IPR2022-01272 Not Instituted – Merits Masimo Corporation
Cercacor Laboratories Inc
Apple Inc 10912501
IPR2022-01271 Not Instituted – Merits Masimo Corporation
Cercacor Laboratories Inc
Apple Inc 10912501
IPR2022-01240 Not Instituted – Merits Rfcyber Corp. [RFCyber Corporation] Apple Inc 8118218
IPR2022-01241 Not Instituted – Merits Rfcyber Corp. [RFCyber Corporation] Apple Inc 8448855
IPR2022-01273 Not Instituted – Merits Masimo Corporation
Cercacor Laboratories Inc
Apple Inc 10912502
IPR2022-01210 Instituted Largan Precision Co., Ltd. [Largan Precision] Motorola Mobility LLC 9696519
IPR2022-00367 Instituted XR Communications LLC Apple Inc
HP, Inc.
Amazon.com, Inc
Amazon.com Services, LLC
10715235
PGR2022-00050 Instituted Shenzhen Svakom Technology Co. Ltd. [Svakom Investment (USA), Inc.] Danxiao Information Technology Ltd. 11134041
IPR2022-00473 Instituted Ecofactor, Inc. [Trane Technologies plc]
ECOF INC
Google LLC
Ecobee Technologies ULC
8751186
IPR2022-01248 Instituted Smart Mobile Technologies LLC Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Apple Inc
Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
8842653
IPR2022-01460 Instituted Ecofactor, Inc. [Trane Technologies plc] Ecobee Technologies ULC 8751186
IPR2022-01256 Instituted Rfcyber Corp. [RFCyber Corporation] Apple Inc 11018724
IPR2022-01353 Instituted XR Communications LLC Amazon.com, Inc
Amazon.com Services, LLC
10715235
IPR2022-01264 Instituted Wirtgen America, Inc. [Deere & Company]
Writgen America, Inc [Deere & Company]
Caterpillar, Inc. 9879390
IPR2022-01239 Instituted Rfcyber Corp. [RFCyber Corporation] Apple Inc 10600046
IPR2022-01168 Instituted Invincible IP LLC [IP Edge LLC] Unified Patents, LLC 9635134
IPR2022-01237 Instituted Pilot, Inc. The Noco Company, Inc. 11124077
IPR2022-01170 Instituted Largan Precision Co., Ltd. [Largan Precision] Motorola Mobility LLC 10209487
IPR2022-01249 Instituted Smart Mobile Technologies LLC Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Apple Inc
Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
9019946
IPR2022-01325 Instituted Mayborn UK Limited [Ping An Insurance (Group) Company of China, Ltd.] Comotomo Corporation
Comotomo Inc.
10952930
IPR2022-01172 Instituted Largan Precision Co., Ltd. [Largan Precision] Motorola Mobility LLC 10564397
IPR2022-00205 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
8903307
IPR2021-01264 Final Written Decision Palo Alto Research Center Inc. [Xerox Holdings Corp.] Facebook, Inc. 7043475
IPR2021-01368 Final Written Decision Lynk Labs, Inc
Reno Technologies Inc.
Home Depot U.S.A., Inc.
Advanced Energy Industries Inc.
10757783
IPR2017-01928 Final Written Decision Ironburg Inventions Ltd. Valve Corporation 9352229
IPR2021-01267 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Hyundai Motor America, Inc. 8166081
IPR2021-01066 Final Written Decision U.S. Well Services, LLC [U.S. Well Services, Inc.] Halliburton Energy Services, Inc. 10020711
IPR2021-01152 Final Written Decision Centripetal Networks Inc. Palo Alto Networks, Inc. 10091246
IPR2021-00816 Final Written Decision Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp. [Novartis Ag]
Novartis Pharma AG [Novartis Ag]
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc. 9220631
IPR2021-00721 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
Hyundai Motor America, Inc.
8166081
IPR2022-00204 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
8688028
IPR2021-01329 Final Written Decision Fortinet, Inc. Forescout Technologies, Inc. 9894034
IPR2021-01209 Final Written Decision Atos, LLC
ATOS, LLC d/b/a RIDEMETRIC
Allstate Insurance Company 9152609
IPR2021-01305 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Hyundai Motor America, Inc. 8903307
IPR2021-01303 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Hyundai Motor America, Inc. 8688028
IPR2021-01286 Final Written Decision Tigo Energy Inc. SunSpec Alliance 8933321
IPR2021-01266 Final Written Decision Power2B Inc. Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
9569093
IPR2021-00716 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
8688028
IPR2022-00203 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
8166081
IPR2021-01272 Final Written Decision Ravgen, Inc. Illumina, Inc. 7332277
IPR2021-01271 Final Written Decision Ravgen, Inc. Illumina, Inc. 7727720
IPR2021-00720 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
Hyundai Motor America, Inc.
Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
9355405
IPR2017-00858 Final Written Decision Ironburg Inventions Ltd.
IRONBURG INVENTIONS LTD.
Valve Corporation 9289688
IPR2021-01201 Final Written Decision Sage Products, LLC Becton, Dickinson and Company 10398642
IPR2021-01287 Final Written Decision Tigo Energy Inc. SunSpec Alliance 10256770
IPR2021-01202 Final Written Decision Sage Products, LLC Becton, Dickinson and Company 10688067
IPR2022-00224 Final Written Decision StratosAudio, Inc. Hyundai Motor America, Inc.
Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car Corporation (a/k/a Volvo Personvagnar AB)
Volvo Car USA, LLC
9355405
IPR2021-00712 Final Written Decision Stratosaudio, Inc. Volkswagen Group of America, Inc.
Mazda Motor of America, Inc.
Subaru of America, Inc.
Volvo Car USA, LLC
8903307
PGR2022-00033 Settlement SPM Oil & Gas, Inc.
S.P.M Flow Control, Inc. [Caterpillar, Inc.]
Kerr Machine Company 11204030
IPR2022-00882 Settlement SPM Oil & Gas, Inc.
S.P.M Flow Control, Inc. [Caterpillar, Inc.]
Kerr Machine Company 9879659
IPR2023-00069 Settlement Imberatek LLC [Ideahub, Inc.] Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
Samsung Austin Semiconductor, LLC
7609527
IPR2023-00054 Settlement Blackbird Tech LLC Signify North America Corporation 7086747
IPR2023-00056 Settlement Agis Software Development LLC [AGIS Holdings Inc.] Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless 8213970
IPR2020-00052 Settlement Divx, LLC [SoftBank Group Corp.] Netflix, Inc.
Hulu, LLC
8139651
IPR2022-00468 Settlement Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson [Mobitex Technology AB] Apple Inc 10512027
IPR2022-00466 Settlement Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson [Mobitex Technology AB] Apple Inc 10491348
IPR2022-00617 Settlement Aurinia Pharmaceuticals Inc. Sun Pharmaceutical Industries, Ltd. 10286036
IPR2022-01410 Settlement Agis Software Development LLC [AGIS Holdings Inc.] Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless 9820123
IPR2022-01350 Settlement Agis Software Development LLC [AGIS Holdings Inc.] Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless 9467838
IPR2022-00365 Settlement S.P.M Flow Control, Inc. [Caterpillar, Inc.]
SPM Oil & Gas, Inc.
Kerr Machine Company 10663071
IPR2022-00716 Settlement Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson [Mobitex Technology AB] Apple Inc 9705400
IPR2023-00323 Settlement Imberatek LLC [Ideahub, Inc.] Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Samsung Electronics America, Inc.
Samsung Austin Semiconductor, LLC
7989944
IPR2022-01409 Settlement Agis Software Development LLC [AGIS Holdings Inc.] Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless 9820123
IPR2022-01349 Settlement Agis Software Development LLC [AGIS Holdings Inc.] Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless 9749829
IPR2022-00648 Settlement Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson [Mobitex Technology AB] Apple Inc 9860044
IPR2022-00881 Settlement SPM Oil & Gas, Inc.
S.P.M Flow Control, Inc. [ Caterpillar, Inc.]
Kerr Machine Company 10520037

                         District Court (58)

Case Number Action Plaintiff Defendant Patent
3:23-cv-00113 Filed Besang Inc Intel Corp 7378702
3:23-cv-00121 Filed Flatfrog Laboratories Ab Chemtronics Co Ltd
Chemtronics Usa Inc
11281338
10775935
11281335
4:23-cv-00071 Filed Bell Semiconductor LLC [Hilco Inc. (d/b/a Hilco Global)] Ams Sensors Usa Inc
Ams-osram Ag
7260803
7149989
2:23-cv-00463 Filed Prestan Products LLC Innosonian Inc
Innosonian America LLC
8465293
2:23-cv-00030 Filed Sta Group LLC Motorola Solutions Inc 8014324
8145249
9319852
9049737
6:23-cv-00053 Filed Sportspower Ltd Zhejiang Hongcheng Information Technology Co Ltd D065329
2:23-cv-00575 Filed Deckers Outdoor Corp Does
Walmart Inc
D090187
D059463
D092716
D081416
6:23-cv-00050 Filed Flick Intelligence LLC [Ortiz & Lopez PLLC] Activision Publishing Inc 9459762
1:23-cv-00550 Filed Qualserve Solutions LLC Samsung Electronics Co Ltd 8046489
1:23-cv-00086 Filed Disintermediation Services Inc Glia Technologies Inc 11349787
11336597
11240183
11418466
1:23-cv-00085 Filed The Lovesac Co Grafiti Home Inc 7419220
10123623
10806261
7213885
1:23-cv-00083 Filed Senko Advanced Components Inc [SENKO Group Holdings Co., Ltd.] Us Conec Ltd 11181701
10191230
11340413
11307369
11061190
11333836
11415760
1:23-cv-00109 Filed Gilbert P Hyatt Katherine K Vidal
2:23-cv-00102 Filed Humangear Inc Industrial Revolution Inc 10555629
11540654
11503933
4:23-cv-00086 Filed Monsanto Technology LLC [Bayer AG]
Bayer
Greg Duffy 9944945
7838729
4:23-cv-00084 Filed Monsanto Technology LLC [Bayer AG]
Bayer
Michael J Hodel 9944945
7838729
6:23-cv-00046 Filed Wsou Investments LLC Dba Brazos Licensing And Development [WSOU Holdings, LLC] Salesforce.com 7551731
4:23-cv-00088 Filed Monsanto Technology LLC [Bayer AG]
Bayer
Robert O Pierce Jr 9944945
7838729
1:23-cv-00119 Filed Sattler Tech Corporation Dba Wali Electric Yaqi Lyu
Us Patent No D910645
Us Patent No D853403
Ningbo Kairui Zhaozhi Trading Company Ltd
D091064
D085340
5:23-cv-00153 Filed Milkmen Design LLC 1616 Holdings Inc
Dgl Group Ltd
Five Below Inc
10967776
D096065
D089919
6:23-cv-00052 Filed Haley Ip LLC [Pueblo Nuevo LLC] Motive Technologies Inc 10204261
6:23-cv-00054 Filed Arena Ip LLC [Ortiz & Lopez PLLC] Verizon Communications Inc 8320820
6:23-cv-00056 Filed Be Labs Inc Asustek Computer Inc 9344183
7827581
1:23-cv-00101 Filed Novo Nordisk [Novo Nordisk A/S]
Novo Nordisk As
Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc
Viatris Inc
8129343
11318191
8536122
10888605
9764003
4:23-cv-00076 Filed Handi-craft Co Michael L Mcginley
S C Products Inc
8636178
6:23-cv-00048 Filed Cortex Mcp Inc [Uphold HQ, Inc.] Visa Inc 9251531
11329973
10749859
9954854
1:23-cv-00496 Filed Camelback Products LLC [Vista Outdoor Inc.] The Partnerships And Unincorporated Associations Identified On Schedule A D073239
6:23-cv-00051 Filed Flick Intelligence LLC [Ortiz & Lopez PLLC] Google LLC 9965237
9465451
2:23-cv-00122 Filed Bel Power Solutions Inc Monolithic Power Systems Inc
4:23-cv-00083 Filed Monsanto Technology LLC [Bayer AG]
Bayer
Brian G Irions 9944945
7838729
6:23-cv-00057 Filed Flick Intelligence LLC [Ortiz & Lopez PLLC] Apple 9965237
9465451
1:23-mc-00003 Filed Prolitec Inc Core Design Inc
3:23-cv-00216 Filed Puradigm LLC Vollara LLC
Activepure Medical LLC
Activepure Technologies LLC
Aerus Enterprise LLC
Ars Home Solutions LLC
et al.
9867897
8585979
2:23-cv-00031 Filed Nariste Networks Pty Ltd Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
Samsung Electronics America Inc
RE04820
1:23-cv-00093 Filed Health Tracker Systems LLC Lenovo Inc 6582380
1:23-cv-20253 Filed Qualserve Solutions LLC Lg Electronics Inc 8046489
2:23-cv-00027 Filed Speir Technologies Ltd [Atlantic IP Services Limited] Tcl Communication Technology Holdings Ltd
Tct Mobile International Ltd
Tcl Electronics Holdings Ltd
Tcl Technology Group Corp
Tcl Communication Ltd
et al.
8345780
2:23-cv-00025 Filed Winterspring Digital LLC Renesas Electronics Corp 7164692
7774468
7420975
4:23-cv-00087 Filed Monsanto Technology LLC [Bayer AG]
Bayer
Danny Glass 9944945
7838729
6:23-cv-00047 Filed Recog Ip LLC [IPValuation Partners, LLC] Williams-sonoma 7296062
4:23-cv-00070 Filed Bell Semiconductor LLC [Hilco Inc. (d/b/a Hilco Global)] Ams Sensors Usa Inc
Ams-osram Ag
7007259
1:23-cv-00087 Filed Attentive Mobile Inc Stodge Inc 11416897
11553074
11416887
2:23-cv-00553 Filed Elkay Plastics Co Inc The Fresh Group Ltd 9650178
0:23-cv-00199 Filed S J Electro Systems LLC Alderon Industries LLC 8737672
3:23-cv-00210 Filed Haley Ip LLC [Pueblo Nuevo LLC] Gps Insight LLC 10204261
4:23-cv-03009 Filed Franklin Armory Holdings Inc
Franklin Armory Inc
Ak Build Tools LLC
Todd Alex Rice
10393461
2:23-cv-00131 Filed Wag Acquisition LLC [Woodsford Litigation Funding] Icf Technology Group Inc 10567453
2:23-cv-00035 Filed Throughtek Co Ltd Micro Center Inc
Walmart Inc
Ebay Inc
Home Depot Usa Inc
Amazoncom Inc
et al.
2:23-cv-00024 Filed Winterspring Digital LLC Marvell Technology Group Ltd
Marvell International Ltd
7164692
7774468
7420975
2:23-cv-00028 Filed Besang Inc Micron Semiconductor Products Inc
Micron Technology Texas LLC
Micron Technology Inc
7378702
1:23-cv-00077 Filed Anholt Technologies Inc
Qfix Systems LLC
Klarity Medical Products LLC 11364088
1:23-cv-00080 Filed Cambria County Association For The Blind And Handicapped Inc Affordable Wire Management LLC 11349291
10177551
1:23-cv-00225 Filed Aob Products Company [Smith & Wesson Brands, Inc.] Allen Company Inc The 8011129
10859336
763187
9151561
9702653
8621773
8695985
3:23-cv-00066 Filed Millennium Outdoors Wal Martcom Usa LLC
Walmart Inc
Hangzhou Great Star Industrial Co Ltd
D072704
4:23-cv-00069 Filed Bell Semiconductor LLC [Hilco Inc. (d/b/a Hilco Global)] Ams Sensors Usa Inc
Ams-osram Ag
7231626
7396760
3:23-cv-00187 Filed Contiguity LLC [Jeffrey M. Gross] Traffic Logix Corporation 8031084
4:23-cv-00085 Filed Monsanto Technology LLC [Bayer AG]
Bayer
Caleb Duffy 9944945
7838729
2:23-cv-00034 Filed New Amsterdam LLC Osteopore International Pte Ltd 7833253

Image Source: Deposit Photos
Image ID:40634949
Copyright:Dmitry_Guzhanin 

Share

Warning & Disclaimer: The pages, articles and comments on IPWatchdog.com do not constitute legal advice, nor do they create any attorney-client relationship. The articles published express the personal opinion and views of the author as of the time of publication and should not be attributed to the author’s employer, clients or the sponsors of IPWatchdog.com.

Join the Discussion

No comments yet.