article thumbnail

Judging Patent Cases

Patently-O

For the chart below, I tabulated about 7,000 individual votes from the Federal Circuit Judges in patent cases decided 2014-2021. For each judge, I show the percentage of individual decisions that sided with the patent challenger; or patent owner in each case. That is why the data here is limited to 2014+.

Patent 137
article thumbnail

EDVA Judge Finds Driver Scheduling Patents Invalid

JD Supra Law

In a lengthy and detailed opinion, EDVA Judge Hannah Lauck has dismissed a suit alleging infringement of seven patents relating to coordinating drivers to transport vehicles between locations, holding that the patents were not eligible for patent protection under 35 U.S.C. ยง 208 (2014). 101 and Alice Corp.

Patent 60
Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

Allergan Scoffs At Sandoz Bid To Undo $39M Patent Loss

IP Law 360

Allergan told the Federal Circuit to reject Sandoz's fight over a $39 million verdict against it for infringing an Allergan eyelash growth drug patent, saying Sandoz's reliance on a 2014 decision involving the same drug misses the decision's central point.

Patent 59
article thumbnail

Practical Steps for Patent Prosecutors Addressing 101 Rejections

JD Supra Law

For many who draft, prosecute, or examine software-based claims, the Supreme Courtโ€™s 2014 opinion in Alice Corporation Pty. Based on a number of Federal Circuit decisions in the years since Alice, the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has attempted to clarify the issue of patent eligibility for process claims.

Patent 70
article thumbnail

And Again, Abstract Ideas are Not Patentable!

The IP Law Blog

The Federal Circuit Court of Appeals has struck down many patents on the grounds that they are invalid as directed to an abstract idea, relying on the Supreme Courtโ€™s Alice decision. LEXIS 33719, the Federal Circuit affirmed the Patent Trial and Appeal Boardโ€™s rejection of the claims in a patent application as directed to an abstract idea.

Patent 111
article thumbnail

The Patent Eligibility Restoration Act โ€“ ?Restoring Clarity, Certainty, and Predictability to ?the U.S. ??Patent System

JD Supra Law

senate released a bill, The Patent Eligibility Restoration Act of 2023 (introduced by Senators Tillis and Coons and โ€Žhereinafter referred to as โ€œPERAโ€), which if passed would transform patent eligibility in the wake of the judicial standards set forth in Alice (Alice Corp. 208, 216, (2014)) and Mayo (Mayo Collaborative Servs.

Patent 67
article thumbnail

EFTA-India Free Trade Agreement and Patents Rules Amendment: Compromising Public Accountability and Transparency in the Indian Patent System

SpicyIP

Significantly, the agreement requires India to make substantive changes to its provision obligating a patent applicant to furnish information about their foreign applications corresponding to their application in India. She has been working in the field of access to medicines, patents and IP for more than a decade.

Patent 72